Stone Jake was one of the three lieutenants that mutinied on Cantankerous Tim. He took Tim's eye patch. When Sly went out to find Jake and steal the eye patch from him, he did not fight him as Bentley revealed to him that he was "the toughest guy you'll ever meet." Bentley also told Sly that Jake had a "thing" for monkeys. Sly spotted a nearby anchor not far from Jake's position and quickly improvised a plan. If Sly were to whack palm trees, then Jake would most likely be lured from tree to tree eventually under the anchor and defeated. This plan was successful and Sly was able to steal the eye patch, using it for his Cantankerous Tim disguise.